Tuesday, February 7, 2023
Home Feature news Vass Bednar: If Elon Musk can't force Apple and Google to change...

Vass Bednar: If Elon Musk can’t force Apple and Google to change their app stores, who will?

Musk’s hasty retreat underscores the pressing need for consistent, global standards for mobile application stores

Article content

The digital application stores run by Apple Inc. and Alphabet Inc.‘s Google are arguably the most powerful global digital regulators because they effectively set and enforce standards related to what apps we can access and how.

Advertisement 2

Story continues below

Article content

Regulators left Apple and Google to operate as a duopoly for more than a decade, but are now responding to the power imbalances perpetuated by these stores, increasingly pushing back on the norms that the two companies have put in place, while also considering new rules designed specifically for the largest digital technology companies.

Article content

Article content

In the process, a set of best practices is taking shape that offers a global governance agenda for app stores. As a late bloomer on competition reform, Canada has a unique opportunity to import this emerging agenda with new coherence.

The 30 per cent “tax” charged by Apple’s App Store roared into the broader public consciousness when Elon Musk pouted about it on Twitter following the assertion in the New York Times from Twitter Inc.’s former head of trust and safety that Apple’s and Google’s guidelines could risk Twitter’s expulsion from their app stores.

Advertisement 3

Story continues below

Article content

Musk was not the first person to object to the ability of the App Store to do things like ban competing app distribution platforms, tie access to the App Store with an in-app payment system that charges a 30 per cent commission for digital goods and services offered on its platforms, deterring customers from downloading apps outside of its stores, and more.

A myriad of lawsuits and antitrust investigations amount to a fragmented full court press on Apple and Google, testing the existing norms of the stores. A class action lawsuit in California that alleges Alphabet is violating U.S. anti-competition laws in how it runs Google Play is proceeding on the heels of thirty-seven U.S. state and district attorney generals launching a similar suit last year. Utah alleges that Google uses anticompetitive agreements and payoffs to maintain a mobile app store monopoly so it can extract higher fees from app developers and users. Building on state-led interventions, the proposed Open App Markets Act in the U.S. would establish rules related to the operation of any app store with more than 50 million users.

Advertisement 4

Story continues below

Article content

The EU’s Digital Markets Act aims to make the digital economy fairer and more contestable, and seeks to prevent gatekeepers from imposing unfair conditions on businesses and end users. Japan’s Act on Improving Transparency and Fairness of Digital Platforms similarly makes digital platform providers subject to specific regulations. Advice from the U.K.’s Digital Markets Task Force has informed draft legislation that sets out new competition rules for digital markets.

Other test cases have been company-specific, including Spotify Technology SA’s 2019 filing with the European Commission against Apple’s App Store rules and the lawsuit that Epic Games, a subsidiary of Tencent Holdings Ltd., filed against Apple in 2020.

Advertisement 5

Story continues below

Article content

In contrast, Canada’s current consultation on the Future of Competition Policy in Canada makes no specific mention of app stores. Instead, it gestures at the challenge of data and digital markets and gently raises whether we should create “bright line rules or presumptions for dominant firms or platforms” in an allusion to international counterparts. Digesting the document requires some reading between the lines that is emblematic of Canada’s legislative conservatism.

Pumping the brakes on updated regulation is a recent report from the Canadian Chamber of Commerce’s Future of Business Centre that cautions against new interventions to enforce against digital market dominance. The report argues that the pace of change in the digital economy leaves competition enforcers in the dust, so regulators would constantly being fighting the last war.

Advertisement 6

Story continues below

Article content

While that mismatch is worth acknowledging, it is hardly mutually exclusive from greater enforcement velocity. That appeal is tough to swallow when one considers the most recent G7 inventory of new rules for digital markets, where Canada was not listed because we have been so reluctant to adapt. Perhaps addressing the barriers that prevent the Competition Bureau from faster case analysis and completion would be a more responsible way to address this mismatch, instead of throwing up our hands. Being cautious works in favour of companies, not consumers.

  1. Advertising on Google's search engine and YouTube brought in an estimated $6.2 billion, or $162 per Canadian, in 2021.

    Vass Bednar: Digital ads are a desperate gamble in a fantasy economy

  2. Industry Francois-Philippe Champagne at a conference in Ottawa.

    Vass Bednar: Why Champagne’s intervention in the Rogers-Shaw merger rings hollow

  3. Bank towers in Toronto's financial district.

    If open banking is for consumers, why are they missing from the discussion?

Advertisement 7

Story continues below

Article content

Whether Canada will pursue the use of qualitative criteria to identify companies with a particular level of market power, or what such a designation process should look like, might depend on whether the issue is raised during the small window Ottawa has opened to consider the modernization of competition law. Canada can join the chorus of competition experts grappling with unique business behaviours that have become the norm for all app stores.

Maybe Elon Musk’s recent outburst can do for app stores what Taylor Swift’s fandom has done for Ticketmaster and catapult associated competition issues to the top of regulators’ minds.

However, there is reason to wonder if even Musk, the world’s richest person, has the wherewithal to force change at the app stores. Not long after his outburst, Musk was seen strolling with Apple chief executive Tim Cook, and Apple has resumed advertising with Twitter to the tune of $100 million annually.

Musk’s hasty retreat underscores the pressing need for consistent, global standards for mobile application stores that Canada can help to catalyze by importing Washington’s Open Apps Market Act. But in the online “store” of proposed regulatory interventions to tame the market manipulation of mobile application stores, so far nothing shows up when you search for “Canada.”

Vass Bednar is executive director of the Master of Public Policy in Digital Society program at McMaster University and a senior fellow at the Centre for International Governance Innovation.


Story continues below


Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Comments may take up to an hour for moderation before appearing on the site. We ask you to keep your comments relevant and respectful. We have enabled email notifications—you will now receive an email if you receive a reply to your comment, there is an update to a comment thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information and details on how to adjust your email settings.

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

RB Erlington re-signs with Ticats, source says QB Shiltz agrees to remain in Hamilton

The Hamilton Tiger-Cats have re-signed running back Thomas Erlington and are rumoured to be on the verge of re-upping veteran quarterback Matthew Shiltz. Erlington, a...

FTC won’t appeal court decision permitting Meta to buy Within

/ The decision could spell trouble for a separate FTC suit challenging Microsoft’s purchase of Activision. Illustration by Nick Barclay / The...

The Verge’s 2023 Valentine’s Day gift guide

Gift GuideA few gift ideas for that special someone in your life that aren’t just candies, chocolates, or cringe.Share this storyValentine’s Day might be...

New CIOCAN chapter in Atlantic Canada to hold debut event Wednesday

Anyone who visits the website of the CIO Association of Canada (CIOCAN) today and lands on the page enumerating the group’s various chapters will...